The Wales Times (TWT)The Wales Times (TWT)The Wales Times (TWT)
  • Local News
    • Cardiff News
    • Swansea News
    • Newport News
    • Wrexham News
    • Bangor News
    • St Davids News
    • St Asaph News
  • Crime News
    • Cardiff Crime News
    • Swansea Crime News
    • Newport Crime News
    • Wrexham Crime News
    • Bangor Crime News
    • St Davids Crime News
  • Police News
    • Cardiff Police News
    • Swansea Police News
    • Newport Police News
    • Wrexham Police News
    • Bangor Police News
  • Fire News
    • Cardiff Fire News
    • Swansea Fire News
    • Newport Fire News
    • Wrexham Fire News
    • St Davids Fire News
  • Sports News
    • Glamorgan Cricket Club News
    • Wrexham Cricket Club News
The Wales Times (TWT)The Wales Times (TWT)
  • Local News
    • Cardiff News
    • Swansea News
    • Newport News
    • Wrexham News
    • Bangor News
    • St Davids News
    • St Asaph News
  • Crime News
    • Cardiff Crime News
    • Swansea Crime News
    • Newport Crime News
    • Wrexham Crime News
    • Bangor Crime News
    • St Davids Crime News
  • Police News
    • Cardiff Police News
    • Swansea Police News
    • Newport Police News
    • Wrexham Police News
    • Bangor Police News
  • Fire News
    • Cardiff Fire News
    • Swansea Fire News
    • Newport Fire News
    • Wrexham Fire News
    • St Davids Fire News
  • Sports News
    • Glamorgan Cricket Club News
    • Wrexham Cricket Club News
The Wales Times (TWT) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
The Wales Times (TWT) > Wales Police News > South Wales Police Facial Scans Disproportionately Target Minorities 2026
Wales Police News

South Wales Police Facial Scans Disproportionately Target Minorities 2026

News Desk
Last updated: November 15, 2026 4:56 pm
News Desk
24 hours ago
Newsroom Staff -
@WalesTimesNews
Share
South Wales Police Facial Scans Disproportionately Target Minorities
Credit: Dave.Dunford/ John Keeble/Getty Images

Key Points

  • According to new official statistics, the South Wales Police used facial recognition technology for people selected by officers four times more often for ethnic minority individuals than for white people (as first reported in The Guardian).
  • In 2025, individuals from an ethnic minority background accounted for 24% of officer-selected facial scans despite being only 7% of the population in the police force area.
  • This 24% share is higher than 11% of those people who have been arrested in the area who belong to ethnic minorities.
  • The statistics have been revealed via the Freedom of Information Act and provided to The Guardian by civil liberties organization Big Brother Watch.
  • In 2025, South Wales Police had 271 officer-initiated facial scans recorded: 257 adult scans and 14 for children, among which were two minors under 10.
  • The technology is called officer-initiated facial recognition (OIFR) and includes using a photo captured with a smartphone that is matched against custody images and other facial databases via the Neoface algorithm.
  • Civil-liberties activists described the situation as disturbing, while the police said the statistics bring up issues related to disproportionality, and they will look into their methods.
  • The UK government plans to establish a facial recognition regulator and introduce police reform legislation to ensure the intelligence-led and proportionate use of facial recognition technology.

Wales Police (Wales Times) November 15, 2026 — Ethnic minority people in Wales were four times more likely than white people to be selected for some police facial recognition scans, according to official South uk/police/">Wales Police figures reported by The Guardian on Sunday, November 15, 2026. The data showed that people from ethnic minority backgrounds made up 24% of people selected by officers for facial recognition checks in 2025, despite representing 7% of the population in the force’s policing area.

Contents
  • Key Points
  • What do the figures show?
  • Why were the scans used?
  • What have campaigners said?
  • What has South Wales Police said?
  • How does this fit wider UK use?
  • What is the government doing?
  • Background of the development
  • Prediction: how this can affect the audience

As reported by The Guardian, the figures were obtained through a Freedom of Information request by Big Brother Watch, a civil-liberties campaign group, and then shared with the newspaper. The data covered a full year of officer-initiated facial recognition use in 2025 and has prompted warnings from campaigners about possible racial disproportionality in the deployment of biometric technology.

What do the figures show?

South Wales Police serves Cardiff and Swansea, Wales’s largest cities, and has been among the first UK police forces to use officer-initiated facial recognition routinely. In this process, an officer takes a photograph of a person using a smartphone and submits it to an algorithm called Neoface, which compares the image with custody mugshots and other facial databases.

According to the reported data, South Wales Police officers initiated 271 facial scans during 2025. These included 257 scans of adults and 14 scans of children, with two of the children aged under 10.

Ethnic minority people accounted for 24% of the people selected for those scans. The force area’s population is 7% ethnic minority, meaning the scan rate was four times higher than would be expected on a population basis.

The disparity also exceeds the proportion of arrests involving ethnic minority people in the region. The Guardian reported that 11% of people arrested in the police area were from ethnic minorities, compared with the 24% share of selected facial scans.

Why were the scans used?

More than half of the 271 scans related to people suspected of committing an offence, being unlawfully at large, or breaching bail conditions. The next most common reason was that officers believed a person posed a risk of harm to themselves or another person, including suspected stalkers or sex offenders.

About one in 10 scans involved a suspected missing person. The technology was also used to identify a deceased person approximately once every two weeks.

In many cases, the scan did not produce a match or the person agreed to provide their identity. Where a match was made, an arrest followed in 48% of cases, while about one-third of cases resulted in no further action.

What have campaigners said?

Jake Hurfurt, head of research and investigations at Big Brother Watch, said the data showed that “intrusive biometric tools” were being used to disproportionately target minority communities. As reported by The Guardian, he said it was “alarming” that non-white people had been subject to face scans at a much higher rate than would be expected either from the region’s demography or from the makeup of people arrested in the region.

Aliya Mohammed, chief executive of Race Equality First, a Cardiff-based anti-discrimination organisation, said the figures raised “serious concerns about racial disproportionality”. She said: “Facial recognition is not neutral because it uses AI. If existing biases influence who is stopped and scanned, technology can reinforce and even amplify inequality.”

Alvi Choudhury, 26, said the disparity was “very concerning”. He was arrested in February over a burglary in a city he said he had never visited after police facial-recognition software reportedly confused him with another person of South Asian heritage on a custody database.

Choudhury said police were under pressure to solve crimes and were “over-reliant” on AI tools. He said: “They shouldn’t be arresting people based on the AI tools alone.” He also expressed concern that AI systems may not have been trained on enough ethnic minority faces to ensure that false positives were no more common than for white people.

What has South Wales Police said?

A spokesperson for South Wales Police said: “We recognise the figures raise concerns about disproportionality. The number of OIFR searches remains relatively small, and the use of the technology is in its infancy.”

The force said each deployment was based on the individual circumstances officers were dealing with at the time and was subject to supervisory and force-wide scrutiny.

South Wales Police said it would “continue to review our approach through our established governance processes, which also include input from independent advisory groups and external scrutiny panels”. It added: “Where opportunities for learning or improvement are identified, we will take appropriate action.”

How does this fit wider UK use?

South Wales is one of the first UK constabularies to use officer-initiated facial recognition routinely. The technology is intended to identify suspects, wanted criminals and missing people who decline to give their details when challenged, as well as people found unconscious, uncommunicative or dead.

A similar system is being trialled by the Metropolitan Police in London and has also been tested in Liverpool. Critics have described facial recognition tools as “Orwellian”, while concerns have repeatedly been raised that algorithmic bias could place ethnic minorities at greater risk of wrongful arrest.

Last week, the police watchdog warned that innocent people, particularly those from ethnic minorities, remained at risk of wrongful arrest if police treated inaccurate retrospective facial recognition data as evidence.

Supporters of the technology, including Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, regard facial recognition as a major breakthrough in catching criminals, comparable to fingerprints and DNA matching.

Other forms of facial recognition include live facial recognition cameras operated from marked vans or installed on street infrastructure. A pilot in Croydon between October 2025 and March 2026 led to 173 arrests, including arrests of suspects in rape, kidnap and sexual assault cases.

What is the government doing?

Earlier in November, the Home Office announced a new facial recognition watchdog with the power to stop police forces using the technology if they fail to follow rules and new laws.

The proposed police reform bill includes a duty for the use of face scans to be intelligence-led and proportionate.

The Home Office said decisions on the operational use of facial recognition were matters for police forces, but that their use must comply with equality, human rights and data-protection laws. It also said the technology must be used in a way that is necessary, proportionate and fair.

Background of the development

South Wales Police has pioneered several versions of AI-enabled facial recognition technology. Its officer-initiated facial recognition system allows an officer to capture a person’s face with a smartphone and run the image through Neoface, which searches custody mugshots and other face databases.

The newly reported 2025 figures were released through a Freedom of Information request obtained by Big Brother Watch. They compare the ethnicity of people selected for scans with both the ethnic composition of the force area and the ethnicity of people arrested in the region.

The development comes amid wider UK scrutiny of facial recognition. Civil-liberties organisations have raised concerns about algorithmic bias, mistaken identifications and the use of biometric surveillance, while government and police supporters have presented the technology as a tool for identifying suspects and protecting the public.

Prediction: how this can affect the audience

For residents of South Wales, particularly people from ethnic minority communities, the reported figures may increase concern about being stopped, photographed and checked through facial recognition systems. The data may also strengthen calls for clearer public information about when scans are used, how matches are assessed and what safeguards exist against mistaken identification.

For civil-liberties groups, the figures are likely to support demands for independent scrutiny, published ethnicity data and stricter limits on the use of facial recognition. For South Wales Police, the development may increase pressure to demonstrate that its governance processes, external scrutiny panels and officer training can prevent disproportionate use of the technology.

For policymakers, the case may influence the implementation of the proposed facial recognition watchdog and police reform legislation. The reported disparity could make compliance with equality, human rights and data-protection obligations a more prominent test for police forces seeking to expand facial recognition use.

Kelly Bayliss Missing as Police Appeal Covers North Wales 2026
NSW Passes Law Giving Police Toll Camera Image Access 2026
Tooze Murders: Police Release Man, 87, as Forensic Review, Wales 2026
Police warn Wrexham parents after 13 e-vehicles seized 2026
North Wales Police Merger Debate Reaches Parliament 2026
News Desk
ByNews Desk
Follow:
Independent voice of Wales, delivering timely news, local insights, politics, business, and community stories with accuracy and impact.
Previous Article Who Is the Patron Saint of Wales Who Is the Patron Saint of Wales?
Next Article Wales stun New Zealand 35-28 in historic rugby upset Wales stun New Zealand 35-28 in historic rugby upset 2026

Recent News

  • What Is Plas Maenan Hotel North Wales?
  • Wrexham Bersham Road daily closures for resurfacing works 2026
  • Llangollen: UK’s Best Whimsical Town! 
  • Swansea hospital promotes Tracy Ace to hospital director role 2026
  • Alan Curtis Reunites With Swansea Old Boys in Wales Camp 2026

All the day’s headlines and highlights from Wales, direct to you every morning.

Area We Cover

  • Swansea News
  • Wrexham News
  • Cardiff News
  • Newport News
  • Bangor News

Explore News

  • Sports News
  • Crime News​
  • Stabbing News​
  • Fire News
  • Live Traffic & Travel News
  • Police News

Discover TWT

  • About The Wales Times (TWT)
  • Become TWT Reporter
  • Contact Us
  • Street Journalism Training Programme (Online Course)

Useful Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies Policy
  • Code of Ethics
  • Report an Error
  • Sitemap
The Wales Times (TWT) is the part of Times Intelligence Media Group. Visit timesintelligence.com website to get to know the full list of our news publications
The Wales Times (TWT) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?