The Wales Times (TWT)The Wales Times (TWT)The Wales Times (TWT)
  • Local News
    • Cardiff News
    • Swansea News
    • Newport News
    • Wrexham News
    • Bangor News
    • St Davids News
    • St Asaph News
  • Crime News
    • Cardiff Crime News
    • Swansea Crime News
    • Newport Crime News
    • Wrexham Crime News
    • Bangor Crime News
    • St Davids Crime News
  • Police News
    • Cardiff Police News
    • Swansea Police News
    • Newport Police News
    • Wrexham Police News
    • Bangor Police News
  • Fire News
    • Cardiff Fire News
    • Swansea Fire News
    • Newport Fire News
    • Wrexham Fire News
    • St Davids Fire News
  • Sports News
    • Glamorgan Cricket Club News
    • Wrexham Cricket Club News
The Wales Times (TWT)The Wales Times (TWT)
  • Local News
    • Cardiff News
    • Swansea News
    • Newport News
    • Wrexham News
    • Bangor News
    • St Davids News
    • St Asaph News
  • Crime News
    • Cardiff Crime News
    • Swansea Crime News
    • Newport Crime News
    • Wrexham Crime News
    • Bangor Crime News
    • St Davids Crime News
  • Police News
    • Cardiff Police News
    • Swansea Police News
    • Newport Police News
    • Wrexham Police News
    • Bangor Police News
  • Fire News
    • Cardiff Fire News
    • Swansea Fire News
    • Newport Fire News
    • Wrexham Fire News
    • St Davids Fire News
  • Sports News
    • Glamorgan Cricket Club News
    • Wrexham Cricket Club News
The Wales Times (TWT) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
The Wales Times (TWT) > Wales Local News​ > Welsh Independence Clash: Senedd Heated Exchange Over Constitutional 2026
Wales Local News​

Welsh Independence Clash: Senedd Heated Exchange Over Constitutional 2026

News Desk
Last updated: September 30, 2026 7:09 pm
News Desk
2 months ago
Newsroom Staff -
@WalesTimesNews
Share
Welsh Independence Clash Senedd Heated Exchange Over Constitutional Priorities
Credit: Eos12/ wrexham

Key Points

  • The First Minister, Rhun ap Iorwerth, joined a YesCymru independence demonstration in Aberystwyth on 26 September 2026
  • The opposition leaders, Darren Millar (Welsh Conservative) and Helen Jenner (Reform Cymru), criticized the First Minister during First Minister’s Questions on 29 September 2026
  • Millar blamed ap Iorwerth for putting his constitutional business ahead of NHS, education and the economy
  • Jenner described ap Iorwerth’s priorities as “frankly insulting” and highlighted budget failures
  • The First Minister justified his priorities and claimed that Wales’ constitutional future was up to the Welsh
  • Plaid Cymru rejected any plans for an independence referendum in the current Senedd term
  • Lavrov, Russian Foreign Minister, was quoted regarding UK’s future during the exchange
  • Around 8,000 to 9,000 people took part in the march in Aberystwyth, according to YesCymru estimation

Wales (Wales Times) September 30, 2026 – First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth faced intense scrutiny from opposition party leaders over his attendance at a YesCymru independence rally, marking a significant escalation in the Welsh independence clash that has dominated political discourse since Plaid Cymru entered government in May 2026.

Contents
  • Key Points
  • What did opposition leaders say about the First Minister’s rally attendance?
  • How did the First Minister respond to opposition criticism?
  • What occurred at the YesCymru rally in Aberystwyth?
  • What additional exchanges occurred during First Minister’s Questions?
  • Background of the Welsh Independence Development
  • Prediction: How This Development May Affect Welsh Voters and Political Landscape

The confrontation unfolded during First Minister’s Questions at the Senedd on Monday 29 September 2026, where Welsh Conservatives leader Darren Millar and Reform Cymru leader Helen Jenner challenged the First Minister over what they characterised as misplaced priorities on constitutional matters rather than public services.

What did opposition leaders say about the First Minister’s rally attendance?

Welsh Conservatives leader Darren Millar opened his questioning by referencing recent comments from Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov, who had spoken about uncertainty regarding the future of the United Kingdom at a United Nations youth conference. As reported by Ella Groves of uk/local/wrexham/">Wrexham.com, Millar questioned Mr ap Iorwerth on how it felt to have “recruited Russian Foreign Minister, Sergey Lavrov, to [the] campaign to break up the United Kingdom”.

Mr Millar told members that Mr Lavrov had been “gleefully speaking” about the potential of referendums on the future of the UK. He said: “Are you pleased to have Putin’s Russia cheerleading on this independence mission that you’ve set yourself on, or do you finally realise the folly of focusing on that issue and the constitutional navel-gazing, rather than cracking on with improving our sliding educational standards, getting to grips with the crisis in our NHS, and trying to fire up the Welsh economy?”

The Tory leader then reminded Mr ap Iorwerth that he told the people of Wales that the 2026 election was not about independence. Adding: “Yet since that election, you have done everything to make this Senedd about the issue of independence. You either clearly didn’t get the memo that you wrote yourself, or you deliberately misled the people of Wales and tried to get them to vote for Plaid by seeking to dampen down your aspirations for an independent Wales.”

Reform Cymru leader Helen Jenner told the First Minister his priorities are “frankly insulting”. Noting that his government failed to pass its supplementary budget, she said: “Instead of signing pacts with dangerous separatists, instead of preaching to the converted at independence rallies, you should be making calls to the leaders and finance spokespeople in this Chamber to bring consensus.” She added: “We have made it clear that we’ll vote for a budget that puts the people of Wales first: no more money going overseas; no more cash for trees in Africa.”

How did the First Minister respond to opposition criticism?

The First Minister emphasised the constitutional future of Wales is a matter for the people of Wales, and said: “It isn’t for the Kremlin to endorse, to oppose, or to exploit.” As reported by Gwenno Robinson of BBC Wales, ap Iorwerth stated: “The leader of the Conservative group – along with the Secretary of State for Wales, I should say, because they are on the same page, it seems – may wish to reflect on the wisdom of quoting a Kremlin propagandist in order to pursue their unionist agenda here.”

Responding to Millar’s accusation about election messaging, the First Minister said it feels as though “there’s an attempt every week to draw a big rabbit out of a hat that the leader of Plaid Cymru believes in independence for Wales” – a fact that he said does not “come as a surprise”.

Addressing Jenner’s criticisms, Mr ap Iorwerth suggested Ms Jenner is “obsessed” with constitutional matters, reiterating his government is “getting on with the job of governing Wales”. He added: “She talks about insulting the people of Wales. We can see under her leadership already this lurch to the right. The fact that she didn’t condemn the appalling comments from the shadow Minister without portfolio – without principles, without any shame – says so much about her leadership of Reform in Wales.”

The comments referred to were made by Caerdydd Penarth MS Joe Martin last week during a debate on the pause in scheduled treatments for trans patients. In the debate Mr Martin said: “The Welsh Gender Service should be closed forever and the doctors in the UK who performed surgeries on children should be imprisoned for what they’ve done.” Mr Martin’s words were deemed to have breached Standing Order 13.9(v) as it constituted “disorderly, discriminatory or offensive language or language which detracts from the dignity of the Senedd”.

What occurred at the YesCymru rally in Aberystwyth?

On Saturday 26 September 2026, the First Minister attended a YesCymru rally in Aberystwyth where he declared Wales was “on a journey”. As reported by Gwenno Robinson of BBC Wales, Wales’ first minister said there was “no turning back” on the journey to independence for the country, as he attended the rally.

In a speech addressing the crowd gathered in Aberystwyth, Ceredigion, Rhun ap Iorwerth said the “next step” for Wales had to be “equality with Scotland, as a minimum”. Thousands were in attendance, with the event organisers, campaign group Yes Cymru, saying it estimated the march attracted between 8,000 and 9,000 people.

“[Wales is] on a journey, and there’s no turning back,” ap Iorwerth said. Since 2019, thousands have taken part in independence marches across Wales, including in Cardiff, Swansea, Wrexham, Merthyr Tydfil, Rhyl and Barry. But this was the first time the first minister of Wales had attended a Yes Cymru march.

Following the march, a rally in Castle Gardens featured speeches, including from the first minister, as well as Yes Cymru’s chairman Rob Hughes and Elwyn Vaughan, Plaid Cymru MS for Gwynedd Maldwyn. It was the first march since pro-independence party Plaid Cymru came into government in Wales following the Senedd elections in May.

Ap Iorwerth said:

“We are standing up for Wales, pursuing the investment and greater powers we need from Westminster now, so we can make a real difference to people’s lives as the next step in our constitutional journey.”

In his speech, the Plaid Cymru MS for Bangor Conwy Môn referenced Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s comments on Friday, ruling out the handing of powers to hold a referendum on independence to the Welsh government.

“The right to self-determination is not a right that the UK government is willing to acknowledge,”

ap Iorwerth said.

What additional exchanges occurred during First Minister’s Questions?

During the session, Reform MS Joe Martin said the first minister’s attendance at the event was “disappointing to see, especially so early in the term, given that Plaid Cymru campaigned on a platform where independence wasn’t on the table for the Senedd term”. “It’s not where their priorities and their attention should be,” he told Politics Wales. “If there was a clear and overwhelming majority of people in Wales who wanted independence then obviously that would change things, but there isn’t, there’s a clear and overwhelming majority of people who don’t want independence.”

Andrew RT Davies MS from the Welsh Conservatives added that “waiting times have gone up, and we’ve had the Pisa results that shows we’ve fallen further behind other parts of the United Kingdom”. He continued:

“So instead of marching in Aberystwyth, [the first minister would] be better off behind his desk in Cathays sorting the problems that he said he would sort out.”

A Welsh Conservative MS said it would be “better for him to be behind his desk in Cathays sorting the problems he said he would sort out”. A Reform Cymru Member of the Senedd (MS) said he was “disappointed” by the first minister’s decision to attend.

Responding to the opposition parties’ criticism, a spokesperson for Plaid Cymru said:

“We are getting on with the priorities facing Wales right now – reducing NHS waiting times, improving literacy and numeracy, supporting jobs and businesses, and tackling the cost of living – while also standing up for Wales and being ambitious for our nation’s future.”

Background of the Welsh Independence Development

The Welsh independence movement has gained considerable momentum since 2019, with regular marches organised by YesCymru across major Welsh towns and cities. The May 2026 Senedd election marked a historic turning point when Plaid Cymru ended 100 years of Labour rule in Wales, with Rhun ap Iorwerth becoming First Minister.

Plaid Cymru has ruled out an independence referendum in its first term, but the party has repeatedly said it will use its time in government to make the case for an independent Wales. During the campaign, ap Iorwerth confirmed that he would not pursue a referendum during the initial term of a Plaid government.

On 13-14 September 2026, First Ministers from Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland held a landmark summit in Cardiff, where they signed a memorandum of understanding calling on Westminster “to prepare, plan and facilitate constitutional change in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland”. Plaid Cymru has ruled out an independence referendum in its first term, but Welsh ministers are seeking fuller devolution powers on a par with Scotland and Northern Ireland.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham has said he is “open” to additional devolution but has ruled out handing powers to hold independence referendums to the devolved nations. This week, the Senedd narrowly rejected a Reform motion declaring Wales should remain part of the United Kingdom, with the vote initially tied at 45-45 before Presiding Officer Huw Irranca-Davies cast the deciding vote against the proposal.

Prediction: How This Development May Affect Welsh Voters and Political Landscape

The Welsh independence clash is likely to have significant implications for Welsh voters and the broader political landscape in the coming months. Political analysts suggest the heightened focus on constitutional matters may polarise public opinion, with surveys indicating approximately two-thirds of individuals oppose the idea of an independent Wales.

For Welsh voters, the ongoing debate may force a clearer articulation of priorities between constitutional aspirations and immediate public service concerns. The opposition’s emphasis on NHS waiting times, educational standards and economic performance resonates with voters who prioritise day-to-day governance over long-term constitutional questions.

The First Minister’s attendance at the YesCymru rally, while consistent with his lifelong belief in independence, may complicate efforts to build consensus on practical governance issues such as the supplementary budget, which his government has so far failed to pass. Finance Minister Elin Jones has indicated willingness to present another supplementary budget “at the earliest opportunity”, incorporating an extra £40 million for the current financial year.

For Plaid Cymru supporters, the First Minister’s visible commitment to independence may strengthen their base, but could alienate moderate voters who supported the party on the understanding that independence was not on the agenda for the current Senedd term. The party faces a balancing act between maintaining its constitutional ambitions and delivering on practical governance commitments.

The reference to Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov’s comments introduces an additional dimension to the debate, potentially framing the independence question within broader geopolitical considerations about national security and international alliances. This may particularly affect older voters and those with security concerns who view the UK’s defence infrastructure, including RAF Valley on Anglesey, as providing enhanced national security.

Looking ahead to the 2029 Westminster election and beyond, the constitutional question is likely to remain a defining feature of Welsh politics, with Reform Cymru positioning itself as the primary unionist opposition voice. The outcome will largely depend on whether Plaid Cymru can demonstrate tangible improvements in public services while maintaining its constitutional agenda, or whether opposition parties successfully frame the debate around immediate practical concerns affecting Welsh households.

South Wales Beaches Closed to Investigation Over Pollution Concerns 2026
Wales Toxic Waste Sites Under Scrutiny After Sheen Series 2026
BT compound in Porthmadog hit by £4,000 copper cabling theft, Wales 2026
Swansea Terrace Penthouse Sells $41,500 Below Ask 2026
Fifth round FA Cup draw confirmed for 2026 Season
News Desk
ByNews Desk
Follow:
Independent voice of Wales, delivering timely news, local insights, politics, business, and community stories with accuracy and impact.
Previous Article Wrexham Man 25-Mile Lorry Chase Ends Without Injury 2026 Wrexham Man’s 25-Mile Lorry Chase Ends Without Injury 2026
Next Article Swansea Driver Police Motorbike Crash Driver Jailed 2026 Swansea Driver Police Motorbike Crash: Driver Jailed 2026

Recent News

  • What Is Plas Maenan Hotel North Wales?
  • Wrexham Bersham Road daily closures for resurfacing works 2026
  • Llangollen: UK’s Best Whimsical Town! 
  • Swansea hospital promotes Tracy Ace to hospital director role 2026
  • Alan Curtis Reunites With Swansea Old Boys in Wales Camp 2026

All the day’s headlines and highlights from Wales, direct to you every morning.

Area We Cover

  • Swansea News
  • Wrexham News
  • Cardiff News
  • Newport News
  • Bangor News

Explore News

  • Sports News
  • Crime News​
  • Stabbing News​
  • Fire News
  • Live Traffic & Travel News
  • Police News

Discover TWT

  • About The Wales Times (TWT)
  • Become TWT Reporter
  • Contact Us
  • Street Journalism Training Programme (Online Course)

Useful Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies Policy
  • Code of Ethics
  • Report an Error
  • Sitemap
The Wales Times (TWT) is the part of Times Intelligence Media Group. Visit timesintelligence.com website to get to know the full list of our news publications
The Wales Times (TWT) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?